UoBIP: Appeal of Simon Hall to begin on the 7th December

24 November 2010

Simon Hall, convicted of the murder of 79 year old Joan Albert in February 2003, had his case referred back to the Court of Appeal (Criminal Division) by the Criminal Cases Review Commission (CCRC) in October 2009 following a series of submissions by the University of Bristol Innocence Project (UoBIP). The appeal will begin on December 7th 2010, and is scheduled to run over three days.

... the fibre evidence ... holds the whole case together. It's a very odd case, it's circumstantial, break that central piece of evidence and the case falls apart.

Keir Starmer, now Director for Public Prosecutions

Significantly, Mr Hall’s case is the first case worked on by an innocence project in the UK that has been referred back to the Court of Appeal by the Criminal Cases Review Commission and, indeed, to be heard at the Court of Appeal.

The University of Bristol Innocence Project (UoBIP), the first Innocence Project in the UK, was established in January 2005 by Dr Michael Naughton, Senior Lecturer in the School of Law and the School of Sociology, Politics and International Studies (SPAIS).

The UoBIP is an extra-curricula pro bono legal clinic for undergraduate and postgraduate students who learn about criminal law by working on real cases of prisoners maintaining innocence under Dr Naughton’s academic supervision and guidance, where appropriate, from criminal appeal lawyers, forensic scientists, and others, also all working on a pro bono (free) basis.

Gabe Tan, now Research Assistant in the School of Law and Assistant Director of the UoBIP, headed the investigation into Mr Hall’s claim of innocence throughout its time with the University of Bristol. As a law student she committed many hundreds of voluntary hours to produce various submissions to the CCRC over the years on the limitations of the fibre evidence claimed to link Mr Hall to the crime scene and the possible utility of new DNA techniques on biological samples found at the murder scene. She also unearthed information (which for legal reasons cannot be disclosed at this time) in previously unused evidence that may conclusively prove Mr Hall's factual innocence.

In the last ever BBC Rough Justice documentary, aired in April 2007, that followed Gabe and four other students from the UoBIP investigating Mr Hall’s case, Keir Starmer, now Director for Public Prosecutions, stated:

‘Simon's case is really peculiar, because there is no particular reason to suspect he is guilty of this offence, there are lots and lots of question marks. There is one crucial link and that's the fibre evidence, and that's what holds the whole case together. It's a very odd case, it's circumstantial, break that central piece of evidence and the case falls apart.’

On hearing the news that a date had been set for the appeal, Mr Hall said:

‘It's good to finally have a date but I'm bitterly disappointed...I've already lost 8 plus years of my life which I'll never get back and I still have 11 more weeks to wait to get back into court. I want to be home with my wife where I belong so that we can start rebuilding our lives.’

Further information

The University of Bristol Innocence Project (UoBIP), the first dedicated Innocence Project in the UK, is an extra-curricula pro bono legal clinic which teaches law through working on real cases of prisoners maintaining innocence. Established in January 2005 by Dr Michael Naughton, the UoBIP, which is also the founding member of the Innocence Network UK (INUK), is a collaborative venture of undergraduate and postgraduate law students working under academic supervision and guidance, where appropriate, from pro bono criminal lawyers, forensic scientists, and others.

Dr Michael Naughton obtained both his BSc and PhD from the University of Bristol. He teaches in the general area of criminal justice and the specialist area of miscarriages of justice in both the School of Law and Department of Sociology. He is the Founder and Chair of the Innocence Network UK (INUK), the umbrella organisation for member innocence project in UK universities, and Director of the University of Bristol Innocence Project (UoBIP), the first dedicated innocence project in the UK, through which he coordinates student investigations of cases of alleged wrongful imprisonment.

Please contact Gabe Tan for further information.