View all news

Dr Michael Naughton in The Guardian: Why 'safety in law' may fail the innocent

12 February 2010

Michael Naughton, director of the Innocence Network UK, replies to claims the Criminal Cases Review Commission is a 'champion of justice'.

the CCRC's review of Hurley's case lays bare the real failure of the 'safety in law' approach to alleged wrongful convictions at the post-appeal stage

Dr Michael Naughton
In an article entitled ' Why 'safety in law' may fail the innocent' published on The Guardian 'Justice on Trial' website on Thursday, 11th February, Michael Naughton, director of the Innocence Network UK,  suggests that the Criminal Cases Review Commission (CCRC), the independent public body set up to investigate possible miscarriages of justice in England, Wales and Northern Ireland, is failing in its role as a meaningful post-appeal review body.  Dr Naughton uses the example of Neil Hurley, whose case was taken on by the University of Bristol Innocence Project in 2005, to demonstrate that the CCRC's remit, which is not to " consider innocence or guilt, but whether there is new evidence or argument that may cast doubt on the safety of an original decision"  results in it almost inevitably failing innocent victims of wrongful conviction.  Dr Naughton's article comes in response to the recent claim by David Jessel, a Commissioner at the CCRC, that "innocence project students are being encouraged to see the CCRC as the enemy of justice rather than its champion".

 

Further information

Dr Michael Naughton obtained both his BSc and PhD from the University of Bristol. He teaches in the general area of criminal justice and the specialist area of miscarriages of justice in both the School of Law and Department of Sociology. He is the Founder and Chair of the Innocence Network UK (INUK), the umbrella organisation for member innocence project in UK universities, and Director of the University of Bristol Innocence Project (UoBIP), the first dedicated innocence project in the UK, through which he coordinates student investigations of cases of alleged wrongful imprisonment.
Please contact Dr Michael Naughton for further information.
Edit this page