Embedded Patterns of Text

Often, ideas are expressed in more complex ways than simple question-answer patterns of organisation, such as problem-solution or cause-effect. Many texts may use a combination of patterns to articulate complex ideas. For example, two solutions in a problem-solution argument may be compared and/or contrasted. Similarly, the problem section may be expressed using a cause-effect pattern.

For example:

In spite of these doubts, research by Duncan Watts at Columbia University in 2003 into the use of emails across 13 different countries appears to endorse Milgram’s findings. Over 60,000 people contributed to the study and by emailing their personal contacts, it was found that between five and seven links were needed to complete successful social chains, thereby confirming Milgram’s six degrees of separation. Nevertheless, similar problems to those highlighted by Professor Kleinfeld were reported, namely the use of successful members of society like consultants and the fact that numerous email chains failed to connect. In 2006, however, a large-scale survey carried out Leskovec and Horvitz for Microsoft Research appears to addresses the issues of geography and social status. Thirty billion instant messages (IMs) were examined over one month in 2006, and it was discovered that 6.6 steps were needed to form a link between each IM user. Leskovec and Horvitz assert that their research confirms Milgram’s original findings that we are separated to anyone on earth by six degrees.

The text above comes from an overall claim-counterclaim argument, signposted using reporting verbs and conjunctions (highlighted in red). Meanwhile, there is also a problem-solution pattern embedded in this argument marked by the noun problem and the verb + noun address the issues (highlighted in blue), which positively evaluates the response.

Test Yourself

Read the texts and identify the patterns of organisation.

With the advent of globalisation, English has developed a more plural sense under the name of World Englishes (WE) denoting that ‘English is used a language of communication without necessarily being a language of identification’ (Erling, 2005, p. 40). To put it another way, English is no longer limited to one place, culture or people but is increasingly being used as a medium for worldwide communication. As an attempt to embrace the norm of English as an International Language (EIL), it is important to re-examine some issues and concerns regarding native speakers in Korea. To this end, a body of literature in relation to Korean context will be reviewed in detail. Closely looking at the status quo in terms of students and parents’ perception of the native speakers in my school, some practical and comprehensive strategies to promote a better understanding of native speaker and ELT will be proposed. 

Process

Compare-Contrast

Cause-Effect

Problem-Solution

Claim-Counterclaim



Homelessness has been an issue in this country for many centuries and the problem is not diminishing. Literature shows that between the 7th and 16th Centuries, vagabonds were punished by jail on the presumption that they were unlicensed beggars (McIntosh, 1998; The Nomad Trust, 2009); in the 16th Century the number of vagrants was estimated at 20,000. It was at this point that the state realised they needed to address the problem and set up Bridewells to house them (St Mungos, 2009). These were followed by 18th Century Workhouses which were then succeeded by Spikes in the 20th Century. As the numbers of homeless grew during the latter part of the 20th Century so did public concern. In 1977 the Government introduced the Housing Act to strengthen the sense of responsibility of local authorities to the homeless (Fitzpatrick, Kemp & Klinker, 2000); this was updated in 1996 and again in 2002 (Homelessness Act, 2002).

The Department for Communities and Local Governments (2009) identified reasons for homelessness, including relationship breakdown, mortgage/rent arrears and end of tenancy agreements. However, Homeless Link (2009) extends these further to include other causes of homelessness: mental health issues, drug misuse/alcohol dependency, those who have been in care, prison or the armed forces and other groups such as ethnic minorities, refugees and asylum seekers. Homelessness is not just attributable to one factor; therefore it requires many different strategies to bring about its elimination. Although the Government and charities are working hard to solve this problem, it just doesn’t seem to be enough.

Process

Compare-Contrast

Cause-Effect

Problem-Solution

Claim-Counterclaim



Retail is a rapidly changing market and with the recent demise of many well known high-street retailers, this report looks to understand how technology is shaping operations. First looking at the direct effects technology has had on retail operations, it is clear that there are a variety of benefits which result from its implementation. One of these benefits is alluded to in the second part of the report which identifies where technology can aid operational strategy. However, the research also suggests that these benefits can also come with drawbacks in quality and overall output. These are just two factors demanded by the consumer in an ever increasing diversity of expectation, a diversity explained in the final section. It is fair to suggest that the presence of technology has risen dramatically in past decades, however, it is the sophisticated development that has made IT increasingly utilised by retail firms across the world 

Process

Compare-Contrast

Cause-Effect

Problem-Solution

Claim-Counterclaim